Most people assume that a cost-of-living adjustment is a meaningful raise. For millions of Americans on fixed disability income, it is often the cruelest kind of arithmetic — an increase that arrives on paper while the actual distance between what you earn and what you owe keeps widening. That disconnect is something Pauline Kowalski knows in her bones.
I met Pauline entirely by accident on a Tuesday afternoon in late March 2026, near the frozen foods aisle of a Homeland grocery store on the northwest side of Oklahoma City. She was standing still, phone in hand, apparently doing math in the notes app. I recognized the look — I had written about it enough times to know it. We started talking, and forty minutes later we were sitting in the store’s small café area, and she was telling me things she said she had never said out loud to a stranger.
The Grocery Store Math That Started This Story
Pauline Kowalski is 48 years old, a freelance graphic designer who has been on Social Security Disability Insurance since early 2023 following a hospitalization for a cardiac arrhythmia that left her unable to maintain the kind of client load her income previously depended on. She is sharp, quick with numbers, and visibly exhausted by what those numbers add up to.
When I sat down with Pauline that afternoon, she laid it out with the precision of someone who has rehearsed the math too many times. Her SSDI payment in April 2026 was $1,481 — a figure that reflected the 2.5% COLA adjustment that the Social Security Administration applied to 2025 benefits and which carried into her 2026 base. Before that adjustment, she had been receiving $1,445 a month. The increase: $36.
She is also single, and she is quietly helping her younger brother Marcus finish his junior year at the University of Central Oklahoma — contributing roughly $310 a month toward his housing costs. That arrangement started before her disability, and she has not been able to bring herself to stop.
What the Numbers Actually Look Like Month to Month
After Pauline and I finished our initial conversation, she agreed to meet me again the following week at a coffee shop near her apartment to walk through her actual monthly budget. She brought a printed spreadsheet — two pages, color-coded by category. It was the most organized financial document I have ever seen from someone who described herself as “drowning.”
Her fixed monthly outflows look like this: rent on a one-bedroom apartment near NW 23rd Street runs $895, utilities average $135, and her car insurance — the minimum she can legally carry — is $74. She pays $215 a month toward the $9,200 in credit card debt she accumulated during her 2023 hospitalization, when a three-day cardiac monitoring stay and follow-up procedures generated bills that her then-limited insurance coverage did not fully absorb. Add in the $310 she sends Marcus, and she has already committed $1,629 before buying a single item at that Homeland grocery store.
The $36 COLA increase she received was gone before she could blink. It went directly toward a minimum payment overage on the credit card, buying her approximately zero additional financial breathing room. She knows this. She can tell you the exact date her payment posts each month — the second Wednesday of the month, per the SSA’s 2026 payment schedule — because she has her entire financial calendar built around that Wednesday.
The Medical Debt That Changed the Equation
Pauline’s hospitalization in September 2023 was the kind of event that reshapes a financial life in ways that compound for years. She described it to me without self-pity, which made it harder to hear, not easier.
At the time, she was still freelancing at a pace that generated roughly $3,100 to $3,600 a month in income. She had health insurance through the ACA marketplace — a silver-tier plan with a $4,200 deductible. The cardiac event hit her deductible and then some. By the time she was discharged and received the final billing statements, she owed approximately $6,400 out-of-pocket across two providers. She put it on two credit cards. The interest has since pushed that total to $9,200.
She was approved for SSDI in January 2024 after an initial denial and a successful appeal — a timeline she described as “faster than most people get, but still long enough to wreck everything.” The five-month waiting period required by federal law meant her first actual payment arrived in June 2024.
The COLA Reality Gap — What the Numbers Say vs. What They Feel Like
The 2025 COLA of 2.5% was the smallest adjustment since 2021, when the figure was 1.3%. After the outsized 8.7% increase in 2023 and 3.2% in 2024, the smaller adjustments have felt, to many recipients, like a retreat. According to SSA’s historical COLA data, the 2025 rate was tied to the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W), a metric that critics have long argued understates the actual cost pressures faced by older and disabled Americans, particularly in housing and healthcare.
For Pauline, the COLA conversation is almost philosophical at this point. She tracks it, she understands how it’s calculated, and she acknowledges it is better than nothing. She just does not experience it as relief.
She is not wrong to notice the disconnect. The CPI-W, which drives COLA calculations, is based on spending patterns of employed, urban workers — a population whose consumption basket differs from that of disability recipients in measurable ways. Housing cost inflation in the Oklahoma City metro, for instance, ran well above 4% through much of 2024 and into 2025, according to regional Federal Reserve reporting. Her rent has increased $75 a month over the past 18 months.
Where Pauline Is Now — and What She’s Still Carrying
When I asked Pauline what she wants people to understand about her situation, she paused for a long time. She was not searching for words — she seemed to be deciding how honest to be with someone she had only just met.
She is currently $148 short of her monthly fixed obligations — a gap she fills through small freelance projects she takes on during weeks when her health permits, typically earning between $100 and $400 in a given month. It is not consistent, and she knows that irregular freelance income, if it crosses certain thresholds, requires careful tracking to stay within SSDI’s Substantial Gainful Activity limits, which the SSA set at $1,620 per month for non-blind individuals in 2025.
Marcus does not know the full picture. She has not told him. She told me that with a small, tired laugh — the kind that carries too much information in too short a sound.
Sitting across from Pauline Kowalski in that coffee shop, spreadsheet on the table between us, I kept thinking about how the phrase “cost-of-living adjustment” sounds like something designed to solve the exact problem she is living inside. It is not, of course. It is a statistical mechanism that tracks a particular index, applied uniformly across a population with wildly different financial realities. For some recipients, $36 more a month is a trip to the pharmacy. For Pauline, it disappeared before she could name it something hopeful.
She walked me to my car when we finished. She said she hoped the story was useful to someone. I told her I thought it would be. I meant it.
Related: She Paid Into Social Security for 30 Years — Now Her Disability Check Falls $800 Short Every Month
Related: Her Disability Benefits Paid 60 Cents on the Dollar — Then Her Insurer Dropped Her After One Claim
Leave a Reply